Thick Cake Batter: Common Problems and How to Fix Them

What Happens If The Cake Batter Is Too Thick?

When cake batter is too thick it can cause the cake to be either dense or not rise the way it’s supposed to. There are even periods when the cake may not bake at all because the batter is too thick.

Here are some things to look at to avoid having a thick batter:

Mixing The Batter too long

Mixing the cake batter too much can lead to it being over-mixed. The mixing process can be done slowly to avoid mistakes and it absolutely does not need to be sped up. Take your time to get a perfect batter.

Check your leavening ingredients.

Is your baking powder or soda expired? Is your baking powder or soda fresh and not expired yet? Having old leavening ingredients can affect the way your cake bakes. This is something that’s commonly missed and it’s easy to have expired baking powder in your cabinets. Check that before you add it to your ingredients. 

Following the recipe

Are you following the recipe to a tee meaning if it asks for room temperature butter are you actually putting in room temperature butter? It’s important to follow the recipe as instructed so you get as close as possible to the result the recipe promises. Not following the recipe correctly leads to having issues that you have to later problem solve. And we don’t want that.

Type of Flour 

The type of flour can matter and affect the way your batter comes out once mixed. The thing that you can look at is What type of flour are you using in your recipe? Are you using cake flour or all-purpose flour

Cake flour is known to be finer which means that the batter is usually less thick which means the cake is less dense and more tender. Sometimes using all-purpose flour can cause the batter to be thicker depending on the type of combination of ingredients you’re using. 

Are you using the correct amount of flour? Especially if you are measuring by volume instead of weight. you want to make sure that you are spooning your flour to ensure that it is accurate in the recipe to get the right consistency in your batter.

How Long Should You Let Cake Batter Sit?

A cake batter should sit no longer than an hour to 2 hours at the most. This will depend on the type of cake batter you are making. If it’s oil-based you can leave it out until you’re ready to put it in the oven. If it is butter-based it’s suggested to make the batter immediately and then put it in the oven.

There are some benefits to letting a batter sit for a little while and rest as it allows the gluten to relax and the flavor to deepen. However, letting a batter sit for too long can affect the rising agent that is used such as baking powder, and risk letting the cake become dense or not rising at all. Making the batter go to waste. 

The outcome detailed above is not always the case, and it varies depending on several factors (such as batter consistency) and the ingredients added to the recipe and volume. If you decide to let your batter sit you would need to observe your batter before putting it in the oven. 

Can Batter Be Made In Advance?

Making cake batter in advance depends on the type of leavening you use. If you add baking soda which is a common ingredient to add to cakes to rise, it will rise quickly as it reacts to acids. As soon as you mix your batter it will activate and start rising. As a result, this would mean that the batter once mixed should be baked within an hour.

If you’re wanting to make your batter in advance it will depend on how long you want it to sit for. And what you put in it. If you use baking powder it may be able to sit a while as it only reacts and rises once heat activates it. But if you use baking soda within the recipe it actually starts activating once you mix it.

What Happens If You Mix Cake Batter Too Long?

When you mix cake batter too long the cake tends to become chewier and in some cases dense. The texture is off. The gluten that’s developed because of the flour becomes overworked and creates too much structure within the batter when mixed too long. 

Having too much gluten develop can also make the cake become too tough very similar to a bread texture rather than the soft texture cake that most people are used to. 

It’s important to pay attention to the instructions given in the recipe. Some recipes will tell you to mix until it’s the batter is a light color or until it’s fluffy. And you would do exactly that mix until it’s a light color until it’s fluffy. If it doesn’t say any specific instructions related to the batter it’s suggested to shorten the creaming time for the batter. Mix the batter to your own personal preference but don’t over-mix.

In some cases even over-beating the egg can cause a cake to not be as fluffy and be less spongy in texture.

How Do You Know When To Stop Mixing Cake Batter?

The sign that you should stop mixing cake batter is when the batter starts to become too grainy almost like a whipped cream consistency. Mixing is very delicate. If a recipe calls for you to just combine and you over-mix it to the point where it’s smooth there’s the risk of the batter becoming dense. 

For example, mixing muffin batter is known to just call for it being combined, nothing more. If you over-mix it the muffin becomes too tough. The same for cake usually the cake batter calls to be mixed until it is Fluffy and light using the creaming method but if you over-mix it creates too much structure. The cake becomes very chewy and not light and fluffy. 

The way you mix your batter can make or break the way your baked dessert comes out. It’s important to mix exactly the way the batter should be mixed depending on what you’re making whether that’s cake, muffin, or cookies.

To be frank over mixing usually happens if people are overthinking when they’re making their batter or they’re just not paying attention. It’s better to mix at a slow or medium speed than to mix at a high speed and risk overmixing for too long. 

Something you can try is mixing for 30 to 60 seconds at a time and then stopping and analyzing your batter. Then repeating this process until it gets to a point where you feel it has reached the fluffiness you’re going for or a certain color. 

If you’re worried about over-mixing or under-mixing and mixing batter is something that you are trying to master. Try the reverse creaming method.

Using the reverse creaming method allows some wiggle room to make mistakes when it comes to mixing. This method doesn’t start off with mixing the butter and sugar first. 

In this method, butter and fat are added to the dry ingredients because of the specific order, it discourages the development of gluten. During this specific step, water is withheld while mixing the dry ingredients with the fats so when you mix it for too long it ends up creating a really nice structure. Gluten in this case isn’t developed as fast it is slowed down. As opposed to the creamy method where gluten develops quickly. 

Fats in the recipe—such as butter, oil, and milk—keep cakes moist. They also prevent gluten from developing so quickly. The only reason why it is suggested to mix the batter using this method is to create air. Else the cake would be dense otherwise without any mixing.

Recent Posts